Karen Comer

Collecting Stories

  • Home
  • About Me
  • Book Reviews
    • Adult Fiction
    • Adult Non-Fiction
    • Young Adult Fiction
    • Children’s Fiction
    • Picture Books
  • Writing Resources
    • Writing Resources – Adults
    • Writing Resources – Children
    • Writing Notes
  • Editing and Workshop Services
  • Reading List
    • Reading List 2018
    • Reading List 2017
    • Reading List 2016
    • Reading List 2015
  • Blog
  • Contact

Red sings from treetops – book review

February 26, 2016 by Karen Comer 4 Comments

Red sings from treetops

I pulled this lush, beautifully written, gorgeously illustrated picture book out for Miss 9 to read. She needed to describe her physical features, and this was the perfect book to jumpstart her imagination – even though it has nothing to do with descriptions of people.

Let me explain.

This book, Red sings from treetops, a year in color, is a Caldecott Honour book. It was written by Joyce Sidman, illustrated by Pamela Zagarenski, and published in the US in 2009.

The book begins in spring, and follows the seasons of the year. (Australians, be warned that autumn is, of course, fall in this book. And our ‘colour’ is ‘color’ – important to explain this to kids if they are reading the words themselves.) Each season goes through the many variations of colour – red, yellow, purple, black, white, blue, pink, green etc.

Like all the best picture books, it’s hard to separate the illustrations from the words. Zagarenski used mixed media on wood, along with computer illustrations, to create the layered pages. She uses a lot of paper with text on it for the collage components – something I love to do in art as well.

A picture of geese flying in the sky and an acorn in a hand is accompanied by this text for autumn –

Brown,
fat and glossy,
rises in honking flocks.
Brown rustles and whispers underfoot.
Brown gleams in my hand:
a tiny round house,
dolloped with roof.

This book may not be for every family – there’s no plot apart from the passing of the seasons. BUT, it is an excellent resource for teachers and parents. So many possibilities – poetry, colour, art, descriptions, seasons, nature, change, growth, senses …

Here’s the description of blue for summer –

And where is blue?
Humming, shimmering,
snoozing in the lazy haze.
Dancing on water
with yellow and green.
In summer,
Blue grows new names:
turquoise, azure, cerulean.

Love that last phrase – imagine guiding a group of ten year-olds to grow new names for other colours!

And here’s Miss 9’s description of herself –

My hair is medium in length and light brown-coloured. My eyes are the colour of bluebells singing in the sun. My hands are like a knife cutting through the water. My voice makes hearts sing.

An hour after I wrote this post, Mr 12 asked me for some help with his poetry homework. So I pointed him in the direction of Red sings from treetops, and found a few examples of metaphors for him. And this is his poem –

BLACK

Black is night, mysterious and unpredictable,
Black is my T-shirt, warm and comfortable.
Black is a crow, silent and unforgiving,
Black is a cat, friendly and trustworthy.
Black is death, cold and dark,
Black is ebony, tall and strong.
Black is sleep, dreaming and motionless,
Black is a vampire’s heart, bloodthirsty and evil.
Black is a sweep, tall and dusty,
Black is a starless night, beautiful and dark.

So if you pass a girl with eyes the colour of bluebells or a boy with a comfortable black t-shirt, you’ll know they belong to me!

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email
«
»

Filed Under: Children's Fiction Tagged With: book review, children's fiction, picture books

Comments

  1. Terri Dixon says

    February 26, 2016 at 9:54 am

    Your children have your gift with words, Karen. Amazing poetry from them.

    Terri.

    Reply
    • Karen Comer says

      February 26, 2016 at 5:53 pm

      Thank you, Terri – I felt very proud!

      Reply
  2. Carolyn says

    February 26, 2016 at 9:48 pm

    Oh my heart would have sung if my kiddies had written those words! I remember when my boy was in prep he came home one day and said a year 1 girl had spoken to him and her hair was ‘the colour of sunshine’! What a wonderful book for teaching children how to think about language.

    Reply
    • Karen Comer says

      February 27, 2016 at 9:20 am

      Thanks, Carolyn – I hope your son’s next girlfriend receives beautiful compliments like his earlier one!

      Reply

Leave a Reply to Terri Dixon Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Connect with me

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Recent Posts

  • Memory stories
  • Poetry workshop for kids – school holidays
  • My violin, my violin
  • Cassandra speaks – book review
  • ‘The practice’ by Seth Godin – review

Copyright © 2021 · Karen Comer website by LMB web design

Copyright © 2021 · Blossom Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.