23 June 2017 | Children's Fiction

The magic of Harry Potter – still there after twenty years


Mr 8 – who used to be Mr 7 until last week! – received the illustrated version of the first Harry Potter book for his birthday. It wasn’t as exciting as his Ninjago lego set but he did feel a little puffed, finally deemed old enough to read Harry Potter.

We read it in a week. I read the first third to him, with him reading a few pages to me each night. Then he became engrossed in the story, and a chapter a night just didn’t cut it. There was also the motivation of watching the movie – which he hasn’t seen – once he had read the book.

He had hundreds of questions.

  • On reading the letter inviting Harry to study at Hogwarts – maybe I’m really a wizard, even though you’re all muggles. Does that mean when I turn 11, I’ll get a letter from Hogwarts, too?
  • When Harry received the Invisibility Cloak – who gave it to him? Was it Dumbledore?
  • When he read about Quidditch – can I play?
  • When he found out about Fluffy, the three-headed dog – will I be scared if he chases Harry?
  • When the plot thickened around Hagrid’s dragon egg and the stranger – wait, what does that mean?
  • On finding out that Harry had been saved by his mother’s love from Voldemort – do I have love inside me? Would your love have saved me?

It’s been years since I read Harry Potter and the philosopher’s stone, and it was such a pleasure to read it again. I do agree with the critics who say that the beginning and set-up takes far too long, and perhaps that’s why many publishers couldn’t get past that to see the excitement of the story. But publishing has changed in twenty years.

It reminded me of Anton Chekov’s advice to writers – If in the first act you have hung a pistol on the wall, then in the following one it should be fired. Otherwise don’t put it there.

Everything in Harry Potter is intentional – Ron teaching Harry how to play wizard chess is more than a simple scene of friendship – it sets up the climax where Ron has to play the chess game of his life in order to move Harry though to the final scene with Voldemort. The mirror of Erised is there for Harry to realise how much he wants his family but is a pivotal moment where Harry can realise his deepest desire to find the philosopher’s stone to prevent Voldemort from finding it and using it for his own evil purposes.

The small details are wonderful – Dumbledore choosing an earwax-flavoured Bertie Bott’s every-flavour bean, the floating candles in the great hall, the list of books Harry is expected to study and Diagon Alley …

Because Mr 8 was reading it aloud to himself, Miss 10 and Mr 13 also decided they would revisit it too. Be still my beating heart, all my kids reading Harry Potter at once! Now Mr 8 is reading the second illustrated book, Miss 10 is reading the fourth book and Mr 13 is reading the third one.

There has been a bit of wand waving and Latin cursing going on. As you do. Our dinner conversations have centred around Harry Potter trivial pursuit-style questions.

  • Name the four houses of Hogwarts.
  • What is Professor McGonagall’s first name?
  • What ball do you have to catch in order to end a Quidditch match?
  • Name the seven Weasley kids.
  • Where is Harry’s bedroom at the Dursleys?

On Saturday night, the five of us will be curled up on the couch, eating chocolate caramel popcorn from here and watching the first-year students catch sight of Hogwarts from their boats. Hope your Saturday night is just as fun!

Author interview – Victoria Carless



The magic of make believe. Can’t beat it.

June 23, 2017 at 8:03 am


Love it – Mr 8 has love in his heart.

June 23, 2017 at 9:09 am


You could make a trip to a sweets shop and see if they sell the all flavours jelly beans. When my bestie read all the books, we watched the movies after and on the last movie (the name has escaped me) we had all flavour beans.. they are a treat.. stay away from the rotten egg !!

June 23, 2017 at 10:40 am

Leigh Roswen

You are making me feel old Karen(twenty years Gasp!). I remember the excitement of my children when the second and third books came out and fighting (adults included) over who would read first. Those illustrated books are gorgeous – am I too old to ask for them for Christmas?

June 23, 2017 at 4:21 pm

    Karen Comer

    It is always ok, Leigh, to ask for any type of book for Christmas! I am guilty of using my children as an excuse to buy children’s books I want to read. The third illustrated book comes out this October – I think they’re being released one a year. So that’s an economical way to buy them!

    June 23, 2017 at 6:22 pm

Leave a Reply